Welcome to Cruise Talk the Internet's most popular discussion forum dedicated to cruising. Stop by Cruise Talk anytime to post a message or find out what your fellow passengers and industry insiders are saying about a particular ship, cruise line or destination.
>>> Reader Reviews >>> CruisePage.com Photo Gallery >>> Join Our Cruise Club.
Latest News...Disney Cruise Line announced today that the honorary role of "godparent" for its new ship, the Disney Treasure, will be held by The Walt Disney Company cast, crew, Imagineers and employees around the world. The profound declaration is a heartfelt tribute to the more than 200,000 dreamers and doers who make every Disney entertainment, vacation and at-home experience possible. Disney Cruise Line is proud to celebrate...
Latest News...Carnival Cruise Line is adding to its line-up of 2026/27 deployment with sailings from New York City on Carnival Venezia, and more Long Beach sailings on Carnival Firenze and Carnival Radiance. Our two Carnival Fun Italian Style ships offer great options from the east and west coasts, conveniently connecting New York and Long Beach to popular destinations, while delivering unique experiences on board...
Latest News...Vacationers are in for more ways to make memories across Royal Caribbeans latest combination of tropical and Northeast 2026-27 getaways. The lineup of 12 Royal Caribbean ships rounds out a variety of adventures across Florida, Texas, Puerto Rico and the Northeast for every type of family and vacationer to get away any time of year. Crown & Anchor Society loyalty members...
The 'mainstream' these days is dominated by ships of behemoth size - unimaginable in 1976. BUT there are still ships around these days which offer a similar expierience as one typically got in the 70ies.
Altough we lost a lot of nice, old ships since then some of the prominent ships of the 70ies are still around and somehow still operated in a similar manner - the Vistafjord and the Royal Viking ships come to my mind.
Also there are modern ships which somehow continue this 'conventional way' of cruising - AND if one e.g. compares the capacity of the larger Crystal ships to the smaller Royal Viking trio the two Crystal ships in 2006 offer more beds than the three Royal Viking ships in 1976!
So maybe it's not that bad at all - maybe we are better off! Or not?
quote:Originally posted by Patsy:[..] Worse off I'd say due to the number of ships around today compared with 30 years ago.
Are you sure? Depends of course which ships operational today passes as comparable. (..this might make the discussion interesting...)And - as said above - the number of ships might be smaller - but even in this segment the ships are larger these days - which might result in an overall increase in capacity. Also, in 1976 many old ships have been lai-up or already scrapped.And the Vistafjord and Sagafjord are maybe better looking than ever before. (I do not know how the operation of Saga compares to NAC or Cunard)
Anyone volunteering for a list? (..at least for the ships operational in 1976 ...)
[ 08-23-2006: Message edited by: Ernst ]
I think that we are repeating an iterative cycle in which every generation laments the ships of the past and rails against the ugliness of new ships.
I can imagine former Cruisetalkers moaning about the loss of paddles, or the ungainly superstructures of the Oceanic (1899) or the horror of four funnels.
I think this is an age-old process. And to support my argument, I would cite the Royal Viking trio and Royal Princess as exemplars of ships that were thought to be ugly upon their introduction but which are now regarded as classics.
I don't think today's ships are innately ugly - they are just DIFFERENT. Just as the Great Eastern or the original White Star liners are different to Orion or Mauretania.
CunardQE2Cunard CountessCunard Adventurer
HALRotterdamStatendamPrinsendam
Home LinesOceanicDoric
Princess CruisesSun PrincessIsland PrincessPacific Princess
Monarch CruisesMonarch StarMonarch Sun
HAPAGEuropa
SitmarFairseaFairwindFairstar
P&OCanberraOrianaArcadiaUganda
Polish Ocean LinesStefan Batory
RCCLSong of NorwayNordic PrinceSun Viking
RVLRV SkyRV StarRV Sea
CarnivalMardi GrasCarnivale
Eastern CruiseEmerald Seas
CostaAndrea CFranca CEnrico CEugenio CCarla CFlaviaItalia
Karras CruiseDanaeDaphne
Black Sea ShippingIvan FrancoBashkiraTaras ShevchenkoShota RustaveliFedor ShalyapinMaxim GorkyBelorussiyaAzerbaihzanOdessaGruziyaKazakhstanKareliya
NACSagafjordVistafjord
NCLSkywardStarwardSouthward
Royal Cruise LineGolden Odyssey
Karageorgis LineNavarinoMed SeaMed Sky
ChandrisBritanisEllinisAustralisAmerikanisBon VivantRegina PrimaRomanticaRomanzaThe Victoria
Lauro LinesAchille LauroAngelina Lauro
Italian LineCristoforo ColomboLeonardo Da VinciAugustusGuglielmo Marconi
Lloyd TriestinoGalileo Galilei
AdriaticaAusonia
Ulysses LineCalypso
Union Castle - SAFMarineWindsor CastlePendennis CastleS.A. Vaal
FlagshipKungsholm
PaquetMermozRenaissanceEagleMassalia
EpirotikiArgontautJasonAtlasNeptuneJupiterOrpheusApollonOceanos
Dominion LineMarco Polo
Sun LineStella OceanisStella SolarisStella Maris
Lubeck LineRegina Maris
I am sure there are many more that I cannot think of, but this is a good start to what was out there in 1976, a pretty diverse crowd I think..
quote:Originally posted by Thad: [...]Cunard QE2 - STILL OPERATIONALCunard Countess - STILL OPERATIONALCunard Adventurer - STILL OPERATIONALHALRotterdam - STILL AROUND!StatendamPrinsendamHome LinesOceanic - STILL OPERATIONALDoric STILL AROUND?Princess CruisesSun Princess - STILL OPERATIONALIsland Princess - STILL OPERATIONALPacific Princess - STILL OPERATIONALMonarch CruisesMonarch StarMonarch SunHAPAGEuropaSitmarFairseaFairwindFairstarP&OCanberraOrianaArcadiaUgandaPolish Ocean LinesStefan BatoryRCCLSong of Norway - STILL OPERATIONALNordic Prince - STILL OPERATIONALSun Viking - STILL OPERATIONALRVLRV Sky - STILL OPERATIONALRV Star - STILL OPERATIONALRV Sea - STILL OPERATIONALCarnivalMardi GrasCarnivaleEastern CruiseEmerald SeasCostaAndrea CFranca CEnrico CEugenio CCarla CFlaviaItalia - STILL OPERATIONALKarras CruiseDanae - STILL OPERATIONALDaphne - STILL OPERATIONALBlack Sea ShippingIvan FrancoALEKSANDR PUSHKIN - STILL OPERATIONALBashkira - STILL OPERATIONALTaras ShevchenkoShota RustaveliFedor ShalyapinMaxim Gorky - STILL OPERATIONALBelorussiya - STILL OPERATIONALAzerbaihzanOdessa - STILL AROUNDGruziya - STILL OPERATIONAL (?)KazakhstanKareliya - STILL OPERATIONAL (?)NACSagafjord - STILL OPERATIONALVistafjord - STILL OPERATIONALNCLSkyward - STILL OPERATIONALStarward - STILL OPERATIONALSouthward - STILL OPERATIONALRoyal Cruise LineGolden Odyssey - STILL OPERATIONALKarageorgis LineNavarinoMed SeaMed SkyChandrisBritanisEllinisAustralisAmerikanisBon VivantRegina PrimaRomanticaRomanzaThe VictoriaLauro LinesAchille LauroAngelina LauroItalian LineCristoforo ColomboLeonardo Da VinciAugustus - STILL AROUND!Guglielmo Marconi Lloyd TriestinoGalileo GalileiAdriaticaAusonia - STILL OPERATIONALUlysses LineCalypsoUnion Castle - SAFMarineWindsor CastlePendennis CastleS.A. VaalFlagshipKungsholm - STILL OPERATIONALPaquet Mermoz - STILL OPERATIONALRenaissance - STILL OPERATIONALEagle - STILL OPERATIONALMassalia - STILL OPERATIONALEpirotikiArgontautJasonAtlasNeptuneJupiterOrpheusApollonOceanosDominion LineMarco PoloSun LineStella OceanisStella SolarisStella MarisLubeck LineRegina Maris[..]
Cunard QE2 - STILL OPERATIONALCunard Countess - STILL OPERATIONALCunard Adventurer - STILL OPERATIONAL
HALRotterdam - STILL AROUND!StatendamPrinsendam
Home LinesOceanic - STILL OPERATIONALDoric STILL AROUND?
Princess CruisesSun Princess - STILL OPERATIONALIsland Princess - STILL OPERATIONALPacific Princess - STILL OPERATIONAL
RCCLSong of Norway - STILL OPERATIONALNordic Prince - STILL OPERATIONALSun Viking - STILL OPERATIONAL
RVLRV Sky - STILL OPERATIONALRV Star - STILL OPERATIONALRV Sea - STILL OPERATIONAL
CostaAndrea CFranca CEnrico CEugenio CCarla CFlaviaItalia - STILL OPERATIONAL
Karras CruiseDanae - STILL OPERATIONALDaphne - STILL OPERATIONAL
Black Sea ShippingIvan FrancoALEKSANDR PUSHKIN - STILL OPERATIONALBashkira - STILL OPERATIONALTaras ShevchenkoShota RustaveliFedor ShalyapinMaxim Gorky - STILL OPERATIONALBelorussiya - STILL OPERATIONALAzerbaihzanOdessa - STILL AROUNDGruziya - STILL OPERATIONAL (?)KazakhstanKareliya - STILL OPERATIONAL (?)
NACSagafjord - STILL OPERATIONALVistafjord - STILL OPERATIONAL
NCLSkyward - STILL OPERATIONALStarward - STILL OPERATIONALSouthward - STILL OPERATIONAL
Royal Cruise LineGolden Odyssey - STILL OPERATIONAL
Italian LineCristoforo ColomboLeonardo Da VinciAugustus - STILL AROUND!Guglielmo Marconi
AdriaticaAusonia - STILL OPERATIONAL
FlagshipKungsholm - STILL OPERATIONAL
Paquet Mermoz - STILL OPERATIONALRenaissance - STILL OPERATIONALEagle - STILL OPERATIONALMassalia - STILL OPERATIONAL
[..]
Spirit of Adventurer (Berlin)Holiday Dream (Europa)AstorAstoriaArtemis (Royal Princess)Prinsendam (Royal Viking Sun)BremenHanseaticCosta EuropaNorwegian CrownAsuka II (Crystal Harmony)Crystal SymphonyCrystal SerenitySea Dream vessels (2 - ex Sea Godess)Renaissance shipsR-vesselsOrionXpeditionWorld DiscoveryHurtigruten vessels (do they count here?)Noordam (now with ThomsonNiew Amsterdam (now with Thomson)EuropaSilver WindSilver CloudSilver ShadowSilver WhisperSeabourn SpiritSeabourn PrideSeabourn LegendDeutschland
Statendam class ?
Song of America ?
....and if you want Queen Mary 2 (sorry - not Queen Victoria )
I am sure you can name some more!
quote:Originally posted by gpcruisedude:you must not forget the former Carnivale is still in operation as is the Stella Maris, and I think the Europa is too.
The Europa of 1976 sank as Columbus C. in Cadiz.
To your fantastic list for 1976 we can add:
Black SeaAlexandr Pushkin (today's Marco Polo )Mikhail Lermontov (sank 1986)
AdriaticaVictoria (today's Anastasis)
Lloyd TriestinoThe following ships were still in service at the start of 1976 but not at the end of the year..Africa (laid up Jan 31, 1976. Scrapped as Protea 1980)Europa* (withdrawn in mid 1976. Burnt and sank as Blue Sea, November 1976)
Brian
*My favourite ship.
[ 08-24-2006: Message edited by: Brian_O ]
But there are still some nice ships around - enough to keep you busy for quite some time - and many of the ships posted above also sail form the U.S.!
Certainly a lot of really, really nice ships have been lost - but maybe this thread can help you to see the bright side of life.
P.S.: If you extend the term 'nice ship' to include Queen Victoria - and I am sure she will be a nice ship - then the situation is even better.
There again it's all a matter of personal opinion. Some hate 4-stackers, others love them. So when the time comes for these boxes to go to the likes of Alang there'll be mourning over the loss and parties we're finally rid of the boxes.
It's more expensive than a typical Carnival or NCL cruise - but it also wasn't that cheap in 1976 - back then there was nothing around which is comparable to these large ships.
The question is whether there are maybe even more options today to go with 'small and mid sized ships' (by nowadays standards) than there were in 1976.
There is of course no equivalent for some of the ships which were around in 1976 anda re now gone - but some other ships from 1976 are still around - and there are also younger ships which offer a 'non mainstream' expierience.
[ 08-24-2006: Message edited by: Ernst ]
Don't get me wrong,...I'll take BERENGARIA, REX, NORMANDIE, etc. any day. But they're gone; and I can either stay at home, look out the window and long for something I can never have or I can, to quote RCI, get out there,...and enjoy the moment.
As far as being treated like cattle, let's not forget that there were a few ships, mainly the pre-WW1 IMPERATOR and VATERLAND, that carried over 5,000 passengers,...and these were just over the 50,000-ton mark. True, most of these folks were immigrants but that's besides the point. I suspect the scene was more of a cattle drive than anything we'll ever see. And unlike those courageous folks, all the passengers who embark today can look forward to luxurious and comfortable surroundings.
Russ
quote:Originally posted by linerguy:Forgive me but, all this bashing of modern day cruise ships has me a bit miffed. My favorite era for passenger ships is post-WW1 and pre-WW2...but the problem is I wasn't around back then so, the next best thing (for me anyway) is to embrace and enjoy what's out there NOW.
Well as ugly as the new cruise ships are today, its not ALL bad. We have the QM2 and Celebrity's Millenium class is quite nice, especially Summit. As much as I wish they built ships like Normandie, Andrea Doria, etc.. now we have to take what we have got. And yes, most are hideos behemoths, but there are a few gems amoungst them.
I mean Mec1 is right, theyre DIFFERENT. If back in the 1930's everyone was as rigid the Normandie woulod have been a nice little four funnel steamer, hold the raked bow, and a nice big wood paneled lounge. We have to embrace the chance and hope that it gets better over time.
Not sure where I'm going with this post, except to say that I think people gradually adjust and adapt to whatever styling is given to them over time, just like cars, airplanes, hotels, houses, etc. What is shocking or disturbing today has a way of mellowing in our memories and becomes classic in years to come.
Rich
I think there have always been "budget" student cruises (my fathers stories aboard the "Kriti" and "Rhodos" in the early '60's.... )but you can get for a good price good quality these days. What is sometimes called "massmarket" is asfarasicanevaluate, really really good and above average
It is also recently that this happened :with the sad end of Norway, i was looking in old 1999 brochures of her cruises in Europe : Norway's and Rembrandt's starting prices were then actually higher in absolute prices (not inflation adjusted) than what you can get now on Pullmantur or Costa, and Norway nor Rembrandt were in 1999 top end cruises. This is only 7 years ago !
I think there is today more variety than in 1976 : you can still cruise former transatlantic liners like QE2, Kungsholm/Mona Lisa, Marco Polo, Oceanic, Athena
but also, love or loathe them, state-of-the-art behemoths like the new Costa's, MSCMUsica, Catrnival Liberty, QM2and almost anything between, from older like Funchal or Ausonia (pardon, Ivory), Monterey to the 1970's like Lili Marleen or Van Gogh, to smaller contemporaries like Blue Dream, etc or luxurious moderns like Century or Splendour /Jewel of the Seas
and this only in Europe ! and without really breaking the bank (only a bit)
J
quote:Originally posted by Linerrich:An interesting aspect of this wishful thinking for classic-looking ships again: whenever there is some design with a retro-look, it becomes fashionable to bash that. People complain about the use of fake wood (hello, the use of real wood is impossible!), or too much retro styling, such as Art Deco, faux Edwardian, etc.
I dont want to see a mockup of the Normandie etc. in new cruise ships. Just as the Normandie, Ile de France, United States all were decorated with the most avant gard style of the time, that what should be on new ships. I want to see a cruise ship with sleek modern interiors. Not the faux wood etc. I do think that the art deco aspects used on the QM2 are quite nice. She remains quite modern but has throwbacks to the origional QM. Not just for the Normandie's art, I really like the Summit and other Millenium class ships. They are very origional and modern.
To come back to the original idea of the thread:
Looking at the list of 1976, which kind of ships do you think are 'missing' today? We still have most of the back then new ships - but e.g. the prominent liners - like the Italia or P&O ships still operational back then do not have an equivalent these days.
Is someone volunteering for a count of vessels or count of passenger capacity? (1976 - 'non mainstream' 2006)
Ultimate Bulletin BoardTM 6.1.0.3
More Vacation & Cruise Specials...